Site icon Tastebud Travels

NYC Dessert Spots

new york dessert

If you are anywhere near social media, you know New York City pretty much takes the cake on the city with some of the most outrageous desserts known to mankind. So earlier this summer, when Thomas and I jetted off to New York City, I knew we were going to want to document all of the delicious dessert spots we stopped at. Here’s our list of some of the best NYC dessert spots we stopped at while in the Big Apple!

NYC Dessert Spots

Juniors Cheesecakes 2020

Junior’s CheesecakesBrooklyn

Arguably, the best cheesecake I have ever laid eyesupon my taste buds! And I’ve had a lot of cheesecake in my day. There was just something about the texture and flavor. It’s a must try when in New York. There was just something about Juniors Cheesecakes that just blew me away. So much so, we’re thinking of adding it to our dessert bar at our wedding (they do online orders/delivery!


Levain BakeryUpper West Side

These cookies may be some of the most decadent things you have ever tasted. After a stroll through Central Park (or after getting engaged at the Bethesda Fountain 😉 which you can read about HERE) you absolutely must stop in at this tiny little cookie shop. It’s so small, you might miss it! Look for the blue door and follow the delicious smells down the steps to the cookies. It really is one of the smallest shops ever, so grab a few cookies, and get the heck out, because you’re going to want to devour these things! Best cookies in New York City. 


Treat HouseUpper West Side

Again, another fab find after an afternoon of strolling through Central Park! This little shop will transport you straight back to one of your childhood favorites… Rice Krispy treats! But these are far superior to any treats that came in a wrapper through grade school. Tons and tons of fancy flavors fill these cases. They can even do custom orders with different emblems or flavors!


Dylan’s Candy BarUpper East Side 

Obviously Dylan’s is famous, and a chain, but come on you guys. You have to admit, the store is awesome, the candy is tasty, and the ice cream shop is the bomb! We got the fruity pebbles ice cream with fruity pebbles on top and it was absolutely mouth watering! Stop in! Grab a treat, and enjoy the views.


Spot Dessert BarEast Village 

This little hidden gem is an absolutely diamond! One of the best NYC dessert spots. Initially, Thomas and I stopped in here for the bubble tea in a light bulb, hello, who wouldn’t love drinking out of a light bulb? But when we arrived, just about everyone around us had one of these toasts. So we succumbed to the peer pressure, and ordered a toast. And holy cow, were we happy we did! This “Golden Toast” literally melts in your mouth and the ice cream and strawberries are the perfect addition. I would put this as one of the MUST TRY places in New York!


Snowdays Shaved CreamEast Village

Snowdays was right next to our apartment in East Village, and we easily went here a million times. Okay, that’s an exaggeration, but it was so tasty, we just had to go back a couple times. Shaved cream is such a huge trend right now, and honestly I hope it never goes away.


Dessert Club ChickaliciousEast Village 

If you are looking for absolutely delicious, unique, totally out there desserts, this place is for you. Also on our street in East Village is this little gem. There are two similar locations right across the street from one another, but Dessert Club Chickalicious is the most relaxed of the two. We got the black sesame ice cream in a churro cone (calories don’t count when you’re traveling- duh), and it was so good, we contemplated getting a second one. The toasted sesame chips and the condensed milk drizzle made for the most exquisite dessert and definitely one of the best NYC dessert spots.


WowfullsLower East Side 

I don’t even know where to start. Puffy waffle cones are totally a thing now, and I am loving it. We got green tea ice cream with pineapple, coconut, and green tea Pocky, it was bomb. Wowfulls has so many different creations, there is bound to be something for everyone!


Cookie DÕ Greenwich Village

Yes, this place really exists, and it really is good. This place deserves ALL of the hype it gets. It’s delicious. End of story. We were fortunate and went right in the middle of dinner time on a Friday night, and had only a 5-10 minute wait, but I’ve heard horror stories of people waiting for HOURS. It’s good, but not worth a three hour wait. Get the smallest size they have, and plan to share it. This treat is amazing, but also so so sweet.


Buns BarChelsea 

Are there actually people in the world who don’t like milkshakes? These over-done yet overly delicious milkshakes come in a crazy decorated mug and are absolutely delicious. Don’t think you can drink one by yourself, it’s next to impossible. You also can’t “choose” your own design for the mug, but beggars can’t be choosers. If you are really feelin’ it,  get a shot of your favorite alcohol in your milkshake, totally worth it!


Bubby’s High Line

Technically this isn’t a dessert place, but technically, who cares? We stopped in at Bubby’s after a morning of sleeping in for brunch. Which was fabulous! Our server was incredible friendly, and managed to talk us in to a slice of lemon meringue pie, and clearly she could see that lemon meringue pie was both mine and Thomas’ weakness, so we ordered a slice. And no sooner than we ordered it, we devoured it. The pie was amazing. Order the pie, you can thank me later. 


Ring Ding Bar @ Duane Park PatisserieTriBeCa 

I’m not exactly sure how I have gone my entire adult like not <knowing this place existed, but I am elated that I now know. These little pieces of handheld heaven transport you back to a childhood paradise of ring dig heaven, except these are a little more sophisticated, and come in about 47 different flavors.


TaiyakiChinatown 

The whole ice cream in a fish trend has gone CRAZY since we were in New York! Maybe it was before, and i just didn’t realize it, who knows. What I do know, is this green tea ice soft serve in this decadent fish cone, might just be one of the best desserts ever. (Pictured with a skewer of mochi also)

Update 2020

We made our way back to NYC back in January before the Pandemic hit and were joined by our friends Kayla from Kayla Blogs and her boyfriend Ryan from Free Before Friday. We ate all the things, especially all the sweets and explored some new areas that we hadn’t spent a ton of time at. Some new NYC dessert spots have made it on to our list so we’re adding those to expand our list of the best desserts in New York City.

Beard Papa – Upper West Side  

Funny story is that we went to Beard Papa on our first trip to NYC but forgot to get a picture so it didn’t make its way into the post. Beard Papa is a dessert shop all about cream puffs. It is a worldwide chain now that started in Japan, it’s made its way to Texas now but it is delicious so we decided to add it anyways. The S’mores and the birthday cake have been our favorite flavors we’ve had so far.

The Doughnut Project Central Park

A doughnut on a dessert post? If the doughnut is as good as the maple cruller from The Doughnut Project then yes, yes you may put doughnuts on dessert posts. Quick question though. Is it Doughnut or Donut? Is there a difference? It’s like Barbecue vs BBQ vs Bar-B-Cue. Who knows if there’s actually a difference. Anyways, The Doughnut Project brings sweet, salty, boozy, elegant and delicious flavors with their donuts. They have some of the wildest flavors of any doughnut shop we’ve been to like strawberry milkshake, lemon poppyseed old fashioned, peanut butter and jelly and more. The maple cruller pictured above may look like your average cruller donut but don’t be mistaken. It is the flakiest, tastiest and maple-ist crullers we have ever found. Grab a couple doughnuts, some coffee and head to Central Park for some people watching and a delicious start to your day.

Duchess Cookies NYCPenn Station 

Another find via Instagram. We found these immaculate looking cookies last year on IG and knew it was going to be a must stop on our next trip to the city. Fast forward to our trip in January, were exploring in Chelsea and stopped in at Gansevoort Market to get the cookies but… it was closed. The stall they were in was empty, the sign was gone and there was no cookies. We are super disappointed but we didn’t give up on our cookie hunt. We looked them up again and noticed they had a second location in Penn Station that was still open so we all decided we would head to Penn Station later in the day to get our cookies. These cookies are what dreams are made of and were definitely worth the wait. They do sell out at times so make sure to go early. Gooey in the middle, scrumptiously tasty and dazzling looking. That’s what we call the perfect dessert. We went with unicorn (in the middle) and the funfetti!

Dessert is our favorite meal of the day and New York City is our favorite city in the US to visit. Perfect match for us because there is an endless list of NYC dessert spots that are worth a visit to. There is a dessert spot for everyone.
Did we totally miss your fav NY dessert spot? Or do you have a dessert that tops all of these in your city? Let us know down in the comments.

Exit mobile version